Which 45 to get?

[Polak 3]

I'm looking to buy a new 45. I will be mounting the RMR on whichever one I get. I already use the 21sf as my carry piece.

 

The glock would cost me around $500 and the FN around $1000. I would have to spend some money to have the glock accept the RMR though.

 

Which should I get?

[checko 180]

 

This one

[Sota 1,191]

what's an RMR

[BlueLineFish 615]

what's an RMR

trijicon red dot

[BlueLineFish 615]

Build it in pieces. Buy a frame off of gunbroker then one of the complete custom slide assemblies that are already milled for the red dot

[JT Custom Guns 956]

 

This one

Make sure you get one with the Lanyard Loop.....................

[checko 180]

Make sure you get one with the Lanyard Loop.....................

Of course. Only way to be authentic

[checko 180]

Build it in pieces. Buy a frame off of gunbroker then one of the complete custom slide assemblies that are already milled for the red dot

Would that actually save money? Or just time to send it out for milling?

[jrfly3006 42]

Get the FNX..pre cut for the RMR already and comes with tall sights already installed...also 3 15rd mags..head ovee to FNForums and you'll find all the best new deals as well as some good used ones

[Blake 50]

+1 on the fnx. Have one and love it. Just sold my fnp 45 tactical on here last week.

 

By the time ypu send the slide out you dont save more than a couple hundred bucks, and the fn comes with an extra mag, mounting plates for several red dots, trijicon night sights, and an awesome carry bag.

[dwamp2006 1]

I'd have to agree on the FN especially if your putting a rmr on

[DTtuner 21]

I love glocks.

However, as soon as my permits come through, I'm buying an FNX45 Tactical.

Beautiful gun.

[lexcruiser 12]

Maybe this will help...  

Picked it up from these guys (great dudes to deal with!) and great price too when they actually get it back in stock - 

http://tradingplacepawn.com/fnx-45-tactical-black.html

(Mods pls delete link if inappropriate)

 

I also had them cerakote the slide and some other bits 'burnt bronze' before shipping it out.

Love it.

 

[Scrap 4]

If only the Glock 1911 was real lol...

 

 

 

Right now I am also scheming on a .45 ... I just moved to FL, hopefully get my FL drivers license tomorrow ..and then as soon as I can save up the money  woohoo!

 

I am really really considering the Para Black Ops 14.45 ... 14 round, double stack 1911 with premium-combat level refinements and addons.  I am really liking it.

 

There is also a Sig P226 MK25 locally... I always wanted one but it's 9mm... not a problem but... I would prefer the new Mk25 Desert which the gent said he could order me.

[Polak 3]

Maybe this will help...  

Picked it up from these guys (great dudes to deal with!) and great price too when they actually get it back in stock - 

http://tradingplacepawn.com/fnx-45-tactical-black.html

(Mods pls delete link if inappropriate)

 

I also had them cerakote the slide and some other bits 'burnt bronze' before shipping it out.

Love it.

 

 

How much was is to cerakote everything?

[Mr.Stu 1,916]

Whether the slide is ready to accept the RMR is secondary in my opinion. Which one fits your hand better? Both are blocky, but the FNP 45 (yes I know it is not an FNX) I've handled was much squarer in the corners and felt even more like a length of 2x3 in my hand than a Glock does. If neither of these feel good, try an XD or XDm. Still a double stack 45 but the grip size is more in line with a G17/22 than a G21/41. Also pay attention to the grip angle and see what works for you.

 

The lack of machining on the slide can be fixed with money. The size and shape of the grip, you're mostly stuck with.

 

ETA: Just noticed you say you have a 21SF already. Maybe ignore my suggestion on the  XD then.

Edited April 6, 2014 by Mr.Stu

[SgtToadette 59]

Get the FNX..pre cut for the RMR already and comes with tall sights already installed...also 3 15rd mags...

 

Gen 4 Glocks all come with 3 mags as well.

[chris327 30]

Yea i think he pointed out that their 15 rd mags. I picked up a new fnx 45 tac. Last week, and I gotta say it's awesome. No regrets. Mounted a cheap red dot for now until I get the rmr for it. The grip angle was perfect to me. Shooting it compared to a glock 23 I feel much less recoil. Possible because its heavier. But first time taking it out super accurate and couldn't be happier. I would definitely spend the money and buy it again and would recommend it. The grip is not that large. I have small hands like I need to adjust my grip on a glock 23 to hit the mag release. But the fnx fits perfect no adjusting my grip. Any questions feel free to pm me.

[lexcruiser 12]

How much was is to cerakote everything?

 

PM'ed.

[M0ose22 0]

I got an FNP 45 and it has never let me down. Probably about 1000 rounds thru it.  Had 2 glocks and i dont have them anymore. 

[axeman_g 128]

FNX Tac and I think I know of one for sale..... PM me if interested

[Polak 3]

Made up my mind. For under a $1000 shipped FNX45 Tactical it is.

[Old Dog 19]

I am waiting for my FNH FX45 FDE to arrive this week. 15 +1 rounds of ,45 and the gun is +P rated. I have seen pictures of a few non tactical ones with the scope mounted instead of the rear sights. Looks good and I will probably do the same, Mine will be for bowling pin matches and for when travelling in our National park that is filled with Bears. BB makes some hard cast heavy +P bullets that he swears will penetrate the skill or shoulder of a black bear should it attack you. Great gun but a beast at 7.5" long and a little over two pounds unloaded. Ami everything so you can shoot with either hand. 

[jrfly3006 42]

Made up my mind. For under a $1000 shipped FNX45 Tactical it is.

  

I am waiting for my FNH FX45 FDE to arrive this week. 15 +1 rounds of ,45 and the gun is +P rated. I have seen pictures of a few non tactical ones with the scope mounted instead of the rear sights. Looks good and I will probably do the same, Mine will be for bowling pin matches and for when travelling in our National park that is filled with Bears. BB makes some hard cast heavy +P bullets that he swears will penetrate the skill or shoulder of a black bear should it attack you. Great gun but a beast at 7.5" long and a little over two pounds unloaded. Ami everything so you can shoot with either hand.

 

Both of you will be very happy ....enjoy!

[Jag07 0]

Made up my mind. For under a $1000 shipped FNX45 Tactical it is.

 

You found it for how much!? Where? Damn, I'm selling my plain jane and getting the tactical if it is that cheap. All the ones I found were easily 1200

[Blake 50]

You found it for how much!? Where? Damn, I'm selling my plain jane and getting the tactical if it is that cheap. All the ones I found were easily 1200

High plains gun shop puts them on sale for $999 shipped every few weeks.

[chris327 30]

i got mine through grab a gun for $1030. Its a awesome gun and you will be very happy as others have said.

[Tallday 10]

get the FN if you want the RMR.. My brother inlaw has that set up and loves it.

[Polak 3]

High plains gun shop puts them on sale for $999 shipped every few weeks.

$985 for me

[Worn_Holster 2]

Some people scoff at HK's; personally, I think that they are awesome. I would go with a USP Tactical .45, a very accurate, reliable, and dependable pistol. I'd go with an FN over a Glock hands down anyday.

 

 

(photo courtesy of gunauctions.com)